{"id":"79fee09d-2fe9-45de-8989-e1a45107f966","slug":"editorial-how-to-review-papers-for-a-neurosurgical-journal","title":"Editorial: How to Review Papers for A Neurosurgical Journal","authors":["Nancy E. Epstein"],"abstract":"Background: As Editor-in-Chief of Surgical Neurology International, I participated in a panel discussing the role of reviewers in neurosurgical journals. The importance of having experience as a primary author on peer-reviewed papers before accepting a reviewer role was emphasized. Summary: Reviewers should evaluate papers not only in their specific field but also in related topics, avoiding conflicts of interest. The review process involves assessing the validity of the study design, methods, results, and the contribution to the literature, while being vigilant about potential biases and ethical considerations. Conclusion: While reviewing can be challenging, it offers significant intellectual rewards and opportunities for professional development. Engaging in the review process fosters connections with new ideas and colleagues in the field. Keywords: review process, neurosurgery, peer review, conflict of interest, study design, literature contribution, ethical considerations","thumbnailUrl":"https://sni-digital-videos.s3.amazonaws.com/placeholders/specialty/none.png","publishDate":"2019-12-20T00:00:00.000Z","doi":"10.25259/SNI_580_2019","categories":["Editorial"],"fullTextUrl":"https://surgicalneurologyint.com/api/articles/79fee09d-2fe9-45de-8989-e1a45107f966/pdf"}